Marty Moran Tackles His Abusive Past in Plan-B’s ‘The Tricky Part’
Marty Moran's play, The Tricky Part, will be played by Plan-B Theatre Company from May 30 to June 14. The play chronicles his life from when he was a 12-year-old boy caught in a sexual relationship with a 30-year-old Catholic camp counselor to facing that man 30 years later.
Moran took some time to talk with me about the play, his life and Utah.
Michael Aaron: I know you have to be in the subway in about a half hour, so let’s just jump in. Can you give us a Readers’ Digest synopsis of the story of The Tricky Part?
Marty Moran: In the words of Mike Nichols, this is a story that’s really about something else. It’s really a story about a grown man who goes on a journey to confront his past. On the face of it, it is a story of a boy who finds himself in a sexual relationship with an older man, in a strict religious context, at too early an age. But on a deeper level, it is about a 42-year-old man confronting a 60-year-old man about what happened in their past. And it’s really about forgiveness and an inquiry into compassion and the ability to let go of the past. To be able to let go of something is quite amazing.
MA: So, Tricky Part is an autobiographical story of a sexual relationship you had with a much older man, a counselor at a boys camp run by your church, when you were 12 to 15 years old. Has the taboo nature of the subject hurt or helped it get to an audience?
MM: That is a great question. I really think the answer to that is “both.” I am grateful when people write about the play in a universal sense, because it is a human story of forgiveness and how we cope with the past. In the universal sense, that affects everybody. When people get a whiff of what it is about, it is reduced to a sex scandal in the Catholic Church. That has scared away as many people as it’s attracted. Most people are afraid of it. But the play really seeks to find meaning in a difficult story.
MA: In a review I read, the writer said that your one-man show was more of a confessional than a play.
MM: I disagree with that. It drives me nuts when people say it’s a confessional. It is an exploration — a theatrical event as ancient as theater is — it’s a storytelling. It’s provocative, not just some guy confessing his woes. As Peter Meinke said, “I’m not a confessional poet. I’m a guy who is talking about his past and creating myth and legend.”
MA: In Salt Lake, your part is being played by another actor. What is it like to see someone else playing you and how does it change the dynamic of the show?
MM: Well, it goes back to the play versus the confessional. It is a play and it’s gratifying to know that the play is being performed by other actors because it is a play. It is outside of me, even though it is deeply personal. What is deeply personal becomes universal in its complexity. This has been performed in Australia, South Africa, Iowa, Buffalo, Chicago. The only time I’ve seen it performed was in South Africa, played by a wonderful actor. It was jarring to see him at first as he came out on the stage and said, “Hi. I’m Marty. Welcome to the theater.” Then a wonderful thing happened: I saw that it worked as a play, separate from me. It’s carefully structured and was great to see it working without me.
MA: So, back to the story. How did the relationship end with Bob, the 30-year-old camp counselor?
MM: When I was 15, I entered high school and I had this overwhelming feeling that I had to end the relationship. I needed a chance to become a man and grow up. I thought, “I’ve got to extricate this guy from my life.” I had heard rumors that there was trouble; that they were after him. So, in a panic, I completely cut the relationship off. I put an end to it at that point. To tell the truth, the relationship had fizzled on its own accord. Moving into young adulthood, I thought, “This is really screwed up. I gotta get away.”
MA: After the relationship ended, you moved from the all-boy Jesuit high school to a public high school and began acting. Did that help the healing process or just throw you more into confusion?
MM: Going to public school was like suddenly going from a world of black and white to a world of color, almost literally. There were people of every race and creed, girls and boys. It was an immediate release to enter the secular world, where the definition of being a good person was expanded from the Catholic sense of having to be perfect.
It was particularly wonderful when I found the high school’s drama program. It was there that I had an incredible sense of finding my voice, literally. I found out I could sing. I discovered my voice and found that it was a powerful portal of healing. And the drama department was a tremendous place — a family of misfits. Everything happens in the theater. Everyone from the geeks to the jocks who get to play a part with their shirts off — it’s a great collection of human beings. It transformed my life. I din’t know at the time that it would become my profession.
MA: When and how did you realize you were gay and how did you come to terms with that?
MM: I’m sure you’re not as old as me, but …
MA: We’re about the same age.
MM: Well, there was a lot of pressure to hide and try to be straight. Really, it happened to me, later in college. One day I kind of hooked up with this guy who was also nominally straight — a jock on campus — and we ended up cuddling one night. I realized at that moment that he [the camp counselor] did not do this to me. This is who I am. I am homosexual. I stayed up all night wandering the campus in a daze. “This is authentically who I am,” I thought. This is when I wanted to tell my family. I went home on break and told my mom and it was a disaster. We barely spoke for two years. I later told my dad and he didn’t take it very well. We never mentioned it again.
I am so amazed these days at how out gay kids are. It’s amazing and fantastic that they are not struggling with the same terror.
So, I was about 19 or 20 and got a glimpse that this was authentic for me. It took a lot of sorting out. It’s hard when you are sexualized when you are so young to pinpoint what is real. Did the relationship screw with my wiring? But then, there was always a part of me that knew [I was gay].
MA: Tell me about the journey of bringing this to the stage, and then a book, 30 years later.
MM: I’d been scribbling really privately for a long time, since my late 20s. There was a time actually, I was in Utah doing “Singing in the Rain” at Pioneer Memorial Theatre. I fell and hurt myself and tore my ACL and ended up at LDS hospital. I was on crutches and in a cast and didn’t want to come back to Manhattan and deal with the subway and walking. So I went to Denver with my family. I was laying in bed with my knee in the air and these memories started coming back to me — what happened when I was 12. Everywhere I looked there were these minefields pointing to this secret I was keeping. I scribbled more and more. I thought, “You were having sex at 12 years old. What was going on?” I hid it away, but kept working on it. I pulled them out one day and said to myself, maybe this is a book. I’m working on a book, but I don’t have to tell anyone.
Then a friend asked me if I had a performance piece I could do. I told him no, but I was working on a book. They called and suggested that I come and read an hour from my book. I said, “Let me think about that.” I went to meet Seth Barrish and read him an hour of these pages. He said, “This really should be a theatre piece.” I said, “No way.” We did some workshop performing of it in the fall of 2002 through spring of 2003 and slowly it became a play with Seth’s help. I finished the book in 2005.
MA: I understand that you are now 23 years into a relationship with your partner, Henry. How have your past experiences affected your relationship?
MM: The great thing about living with an artist — Henry is a wonderful actor and piano player — is the way in which Henry understood what I was doing as an artist. I was finding a voice as an artist. It was nourishing for us. That the play went so well, he felt very proud. Ultimately, to tell you the truth, we talked about a lot of tough territory. Before anyone else saw the play, I needed to have Henry see it. There’s a lot of tough stuff in there — things about sexual compulsiveness and such. We learned to take great pleasure, great pride in what we were doing. Henry saw it as beautiful. It brought us close that he celebrated that with me. Though he is in the book, it’s not about him. And here we are, still going a day at a time for 23 years. We celebrated our 23rd anniversary two weeks ago.
MA: Tell us what you think of Bob, the camp counselor, today.
MM: Mostly I feel … look, this guy lived inside me like a mountain, a myth. Laying eyes on him brought him to what he really is — a fragile, sad human being. I feel a kind of compassion towards him. I still have bouts of anger towards him — how could he do that to kids? But I saw how much beside the point he is. The point is your relationship with yourself. If you allow someone to have their hands around your throat strangling you, then they do. Meeting and coming to terms with him changed my life from the past to the present.
MA: What are you working on now?
MM: I’m working on a new book called “After They Left” about three very old relatives of mine who died in the 90s. I’m working on a screenplay of “Tricky Part.” Sundance brought me in to the Screenwriters Lab to work on it. I’m also auditioning for the next gig. I completed a run of “Tricky Part” in D.C., which just closed.
MA: Well, thank you for taking the time to talk with me. I’m looking forward to the show.
MM: Well, I’m excited about Salt Lake’s burgeoning community. I’m honored that it is being done out there in my boyhood country. As a kid I would always backpack and ski in Utah. I think it’s wonderful. Q
The Tricky Part will be presented by Plan-B Theatre Company and will premiere regionally from May 30 through June 15 at the Rose Wagner Performing Arts Center Studio Theatre. Tickets are available through ArtTix at 355-ARTS or at arttix.org .