Prop. 8 to finally get its day in court
On the heels of a ruling from the California Supreme Court, both the proponents and opponents of Proposition 8 are claiming victory. The Supreme Court simply ruled that the groups who sponsored California’s ban on gay marriage could defend it in court, even though the attorney general and governor have declined to do so.
The National Center for Lesbian Rights issued a statement saying, “In the bigger picture, this is good news for same-sex couples in California.”
The Human Rights Campaign said, “With today’s decision, the case challenging Prop 8 returns to federal court and we are one step closer to ending discrimination against loving California couples.”
But Andy Pugno, general counsel for the anti-gay group, ProtectMarriage.com said, “We are delighted that the Supreme Court has clearly reaffirmed our right, as the official proponents of Prop 8, to defend over seven million Californians who amended their own State Constitution to restore traditional marriage.”
So who won and where does Prop. 8 go from here?
Now that the right for the Prop. 8 proponents to defend the case has been established, the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals can get back to much more substantive matters. More specifically, the Appeals Court will now be forced to make a ruling about the constitutionality of Prop. 8. And as federal judge Vaughn Walker said in his decision striking down the measure, “Proposition 8 fails to advance any rational basis in singling out gay men and lesbians for denial of a marriage license. Indeed, the evidence shows Proposition 8 does nothing more than enshrine in the California Constitution the notion that opposite-sex couples are superior to same-sex couples.”
Simply put, the case to rule against Proposition 8 is airtight and it is likely that the three judges on the panel of the Appeals Court will rule in favor of marriage equality.
Had the California Supreme Court said only the governor or attorney general could defend the case in court, same-sex marriage would have resumed in the state.
But now the stage is set for a much larger federal showdown. The 9th Circuit Court is the largest in the country and its rulings routinely set national precedent. While the case is likely to end in the U.S. Supreme Court, the decisions made by the 9th Circuit, coupled with the brilliant decision by Walker, will set a strong legal precedent for the Court to consider.
If the Supreme Court makes a decision affirming the right for gay couples to marry, it would strike down all state constitutional amendments, including Utah’s Amendment 3, and permit complete, federal marriage equality.
There’s no doubt that history is on our side. With the addition of New York to the states that allow gay marriage and multiple legal and Congressional challenges to the anti-gay Defense of Marriage Act, marriage equality is on the move.